Eden Lake · Custer, Michigan

Wake beside still water,
where the quiet remembers you.

A private cottage retreat on the shores of Eden Lake — designed for travelers who trade crowded hotels for space, silence, and the kind of morning that starts with mist rising off the water.

Explore Our Cottage (616) 738-0493
Scroll
Cottage on Lost Lake exterior view surrounded by Michigan woods

About Us

Not just a place to stay.
A place to return to.

Cottage on Lost Lake isn't a hotel chain with a keycard and a vending machine. It's a thoughtfully maintained cottage on the edge of Eden Lake in Custer, Michigan — built for people who want to unplug, breathe, and remember what a real vacation feels like.

Whether you're escaping the city for a weekend, planning a quiet anniversary, or gathering the people who matter most, this is the kind of place that makes the effort worthwhile. The lake doesn't rush. Neither do we.

100%

Private cottage

Eden

Lake frontage

Custer

Michigan heartland

Accommodations

Your cottage,
your rules.

One fully equipped cottage designed for comfort, privacy, and the kind of sleep you only get when the only alarm is the morning light.

Cozy bedroom with lake-view windows and warm lighting
Sleeps 4

The Lake Room

A comfortably appointed bedroom with direct lake views, premium linens, and blackout curtains for late mornings.

Spacious living area with fireplace and comfortable seating
Open concept

Living Space

An open living area with a stone fireplace, plush seating, and a curated library of local guides and games.

Full kitchen with modern appliances and rustic-chic design
Fully equipped

Kitchen & Dining

A full kitchen with everything you need — from morning coffee to a candlelit dinner. Dining for four at a reclaimed-wood table.

Up to 4 Guests

Full Kitchen

Private Deck

Flexible Check-in

The Experience

What happens at
Lost Lake stays.

This isn't a checklist destination. It's a place that gives you permission to slow down — and the kind of moments you'd normally scroll past.

Gather the People Who Matter

Family reunions, anniversary weekends, or a girls' trip that actually feels restorative — the cottage opens up for whoever makes the trip worth taking.

Explore the Michigan Heartland

Trailheads, state parks, small-town diners, and the kind of scenery that doesn't need a filter. Custer and the surrounding area reward the curious.

Sunrise Coffee on the Deck

There's a chair on the deck that faces the water. It's yours from the moment you arrive. No rush, no agenda — just the lake doing what it does best.

Unplug Without Losing Comfort

Fast Wi-Fi when you need it. Real quiet when you don't. The cottage is designed to meet you wherever you are on the spectrum between connected and completely gone.

Amenities

Everything you need.
Nothing you don't.

We've thought through the details so you don't have to pack for contingencies. The cottage is stocked, comfortable, and ready.

Full Kitchen — appliances, cookware, coffee, and basics stocked on arrival

Private deck with lake-facing seating and outdoor dining

High-speed Wi-Fi, smart TV, and a curated entertainment library

Fireplace, premium bedding, and climate control throughout

Free parking, private entrance, and complete solitude

Morning mist rising off Eden Lake
Deck overlooking the lake at golden hour
Wooded trail near the cottage
Sunset over the Michigan lake

Location

Found where the
road meets the water.

Nestled along Eden Lake in Custer, Michigan — close enough to town for supplies, far enough to feel like you've disappeared.

Address

5145 S Eden Lake Rd
Custer, MI 49405

Getting Here

From US-131, take exit 54 toward M-37. Head east into Custer, then south on S Eden Lake Rd. Look for the lake — you can't miss it.

"We came for a weekend and left with three reasons to come back. The lake, the quiet, the way the light hits the water at dawn — it stays with you."

A returning guest

Get in Touch

Ready to
unplug?

Whether you have questions about the cottage, need help planning your visit, or are ready to book — reach out. We respond within 24 hours.

Call or text

(616) 738-0493

Email us

rachaelgeerlings@gmail.com

Send a Message

Is this your business?This is my business